iwilltilimwell language

    What Mental Health Care Protections Exist in Your State?

    Insurers have wide latitude on when and how they can deny mental health care. We looked at the laws in all 50 states and found that some are charting new paths to secure mental health care access.

    Accessing mental health care in the U.S. can be exhausting — and often, it’s not the therapist or diagnosis that creates the biggest hurdle, but the insurance company. Even when patients find care within their network, insurers can override the provider’s judgment and deny treatment by claiming it’s not “medically necessary.” This loophole has allowed insurers to create internal rules that often prioritize cost over patient care.

    Some states are pushing back. While federal law requires equal coverage for mental and physical health, it doesn’t require insurers to use evidence-based standards. That’s changing in a growing number of states, which are setting clear clinical criteria, regulating insurance reviews, and demanding transparency in access and reimbursement.

    States like California, New York, and Oregon are leading the way — requiring insurers to follow accepted medical guidelines, limiting how and when they can audit treatment, and forcing them to report how accessible mental health care really is.

    • Federal gaps: Insurers can define their own “medical necessity,” often ignoring accepted clinical standards.

    • State solutions:

      • 9 states require insurers to follow clinical guidelines for mental health decisions.

      • 24+ states regulate how insurers review behavioral health care.

      • 31+ states require insurers to report data on mental health access.

    • California’s law: Forces insurers to follow evidence-based care standards and penalized Kaiser Permanente $50 million for noncompliance.

    • Transparency issues: Some states like New Jersey have passed reporting laws but failed to publish the required data.

    • Reimbursement disparities: In Oregon, mental health providers are paid half as much as medical doctors for equivalent visits.

    • Ongoing enforcement: States like New York have used insurer data to open multiple investigations since 2021.